top of page
AutorenbildJosephine S

EXCESSIVE AND DEADLY HEAT CONDITIONS /PETITION

EXCESSIVE AND DEADLY HEAT CONDITIONS

IN THE TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE



To: Dr. Alice Jill Edwards, Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhumane or Degrading Treatment or Punishment:


This petition to the Special Rapporteur is submitted on behalf of all present and future prisoners incarcerated within the Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ) in the State of Texas, United States of America, and respectfully requests that the Special Rapporteur immediately exercise its authority under the thematic mandate to investigate the following issues related to the excessive and deadly heat conditions in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.


Over the past few decades, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice has adamantly fought the long saga of challenges to the conditions of confinement in regards to excessively high temperatures in the prison housing and work areas. In Texas, where during summer months indoor temperatures can reach over 100°F and consistently exceed 90°F, climate control is not a mere luxury but a human rights issue. It is common knowledge why human beings should not be confined in an enclosed space during temperatures above 90°F without access to cold drinking water. Such can cause severe illness, and eventual death. Yet, TDCJ has for decades subjected its prisoners to these inhumane conditions. As the effects of climate change increase, so do the inherent dangers of confining prisoners in cells that easily reach temperatures that pose a substantial risk of serious harm or death. TDCJ's blatant denial of climate controlled facilities is akin to rebuking the existential threat that climate change imposes upon humanity.



Rule 13 of the 'United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners’ (The Mandela Rules) states that: "ALL accommodation provided for the use of prisoners and in particular all sleeping accommodation shall meet all requirements of health, due regard being paid to climate conditions and particularly to cubic content of air, minimum floor space, lighting, heat and ventilation. This petition asserts that the degree to which TDCJ is in violation of Rule 13 constitutes cruel, inhumane and degrading punishment (See, ICCPR, art. 7; Universal Declaration of Human Rights, art. 5).



This issue has been compounded by the short staff / overcrowding epidemic in TDCJ because prisoners are forced to endure increased periods locked in their cells during excessive heat conditions. Prisoners have compared such to the "hot boxes'

used as punishment in the days of slavery.




TDCJ claims that they provide certain "heat-mitigation" measures to limit the risks of excessive heat such as: cold showers, cold drinking water, personal fans, and temporary access to air-conditioned "respite areas' outside the housing areas. However such measures are ineffectual for the following reasons.




In EXHIBIT A it describes the testimony of two experts on this matter. The first is Dr. McGeehin who was previously the lead scientist with the Center for Disease Control (CDC) regarding health effects from extreme heat. The other is Dr. Vassallo who is a licenced physician and a recognized expert in the field of thermoregulation and hyperthermia with 20 years of experience treating heat stroke and heat-related disorders.



In regards to 'cold showers’, Dr. McGeehin testified that while showers are helpful "for the short term", "giving a person a shower and then putting them back into a very hot, humid environment has limited effect’. Dr. Vassallo confirms that "taking extra showers" does mot reduce the health risks of extreme heat to a "statistically significant" degree. As a practical matter, while prisoners are on lockdown (for short staffing or any other reason) they are rarely permitted access to a shower. The same is true for cold drinking water - Prisoners do not have access to such while confined to their cells.


In regards to personal fans, Dr. McGeehin testified that the CDC does NOT recommend the use of fans when the temperature is above 95°F, and that peer-reviewed publications indicate that while fans may have a mitigating effect, they are actually counter- productive at high temperatures. Dr. McGeehin explained that "although fans provide a cooling effect by evaporating sweat, fan use can pose a significant risk when the heat index exceeds... 99 degrees Fahrenheit... because it serves to increase heat stress by blowing air that is warmer then body temperature over the skin surface". Dr. Vassallo added that "fans are not protective at temperature 90 degrees with the humidity of 35 percent or more".



This is extremely significant because while confined in a cell, a personal fan is the only "heat-mitigation" accessable to a prisoner during extreme heat and such is actually harmful. TDCJ's inadequate attempts to mitigate the heat has actually

exasperated the dangers to prisoners.




In regards to ‘respite areas', Dr. McGeehin observed that, while respite areas might theoretically be an effective measure, their effectiveness depends on being available to prisoners upon request. Dr. Vassallo testified that the respite areas are not "an adequate plan to deal with the heat risk" precisely ‘because they are only temporary and so "the time [the prisoners] ave not in air-conditioning, they are subjected to the temperature... which are risky and cause harm, including sickness, morbidity and mortality". Dr. Vassallo also noted that the harmful effects of excessive heat can begin to occur BEFORE an individual might feel the need to go to an air-conditioned space.



As a practical matter, prisoners have reported that it is near impossible to get permission to use the respite areas and that officers require the prisoner to already exhibit harm by the extreme heat before they can have any relief. Again, the dangers are compounded by short staffing because it is often hours before a prisoner can make contact with an officer while on lockdown.



As such, the current measures used to mitigate the extreme heat conditions in Texas prisons are inadequate to meaningfully reduce the serious risk of harm to prisoners. The only effective way to mitigate the risk is to prevent the conditions by mandating that all housing and work areas be air-conditioned. Without such measures to prevent the conditions that pose a serious risk to prisoners, rather than merely mitigating the effects, Texas prisoners will continue to endure excessive heat conditions that will only increase with the existential threat of climate change.






Respectfully Submitted,




Justin Panus #02167693

TDCJ

Robertson Unit

P.O. Box 660400

Dallas, Texas 75266-0400



Scott Zirus #01640002

TDCJ

Robertson Unit

P.O. Box 660400

Dallas, Texas 75266-0400

7 Ansichten0 Kommentare

Aktuelle Beiträge

Alle ansehen

Texas Triad of Injustice

By Justin Panus, TDCJ #02167693. August 24, 2023 I would like to present to you a petition I helped submit in 2022 to a body of the...

THE STAFF SHORTAGE /PETITION

THE STAFF SHORTAGE / OVERCROWDING EPIDEMIC IN THE TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE To: Dr. Alice Jill Edwards, Special Rapporteur on...

Petition - Inhumane Feeding

INHUMANE FEEDING PRACTICES IN THE TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE (AGGRAVATED BY CURRENT ECONOMIC CRISIS AND PENDING GLOBAL FOOD...

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Beitrag: Blog2_Post

Kontakt / Contact

Danke für's Absenden!

Beitrag: Kontakt
Untitled

Der erste Brief / The first letter 


Was schreibt man als erstes an einen Häftling? Komischerweise, hatte ich keine Probleme die passenden Worte zu finden. Einfach alles fühlte sich ganz natürlich an, als würde ich seine Seele schon sehr lange kennen. (Nein, nicht im romantischen Sinne.) Ich spürte einfach eine tiefe Verbundenheit. Bei einem Verbündeten stellt sich die Frage nicht, welche Themen angebracht sind. Mein erster Brief an ihn war 10 Seiten lang. Ich musste mich quasi bremsen, denn an Ideen mangelte es nicht. Ich erzählte ihm über Intuition, wie ich ihn gefunden habe, über die Macht der Gedanken. Meine Träume und Wünsche. Einfach alles, was mir auf der Seele lag und wovon ich genau wusste, dass er weiß wovon ich rede. Eine Woche habe ich gebraucht um zu überlegen, ob ich das wirklich möchte. Man hört schließlich von Gefahren und Warnungen was solche Brieffreundschaften betrifft. Aber wie kann ich meiner Intuition eine Abfuhr erteilen? Garnicht, ganz genau! Also ab zur Post damit. 22 Tage habe ich gewartet... Dann war sie da, seine Antwort. Nicht nur die Antwort auf meinen Brief, sondern auch die Antwort auf meine Intuition. Auf 14 Seiten schrieb er genauso, wie ich es gehofft hatte. Das ist die Seele, die ich schon kenne. Kein Zweifel. 



What is the first thing you write to a prisoner? Strangely enough, I had no trouble finding the right words. Just everything felt natural, as if I had known his soul for a very long time. (No, not in the romantic sense.) I just felt a deep connection. With an ally, there is no question about what topics are appropriate. My first letter to him was 10 pages long. I had to sort of slow myself down, because there was no shortage of ideas. I told him about intuition, how I found it, about the power of thoughts. My dreams and wishes. Just everything that was on my mind and that I knew he knew what I was talking about. It took me a week to think about whether I really wanted this. After all, one hears of dangers and warnings concerning such pen pals. But how can I refuse my intuition? Not at all, exactly! So off to the post office with it. 22 days I waited... Then there it was, his answer. Not only the answer to my letter, but also the answer to my intuition. On 14 pages he wrote exactly as I had hoped. This is the soul I already know. No doubt about it.

Die Anfänge / The beginnings

2022, nach einem wundervoll inspirierendem Abend bei einer Freundin, folgte ich meiner Intuition auf der Suche nach... Ja, nach was eigentlich? Das wusste ich zu diesem Zeitpunkt noch nicht. Ich vertraute meiner inneren Stimme und ließ mich einfach leiten. In den Tiefen weiten des Internets, durchforstete ich Seiten nach Schreibutensilien. Ich liebe alte Füllfederhalter, Kugelschreiber, schönes Papier und tolle Briefumschläge. Stundenlang sah ich mir antike Füller an, las Poesie und Kurzgeschichten, bis ich auf einer Seite für Brieffreundschaften landete. Ich dachte mir, es sei nett, mal wieder etwas anderes in meinem Briefkasten zu finden, als Rechnungen. Irgendwie spürte ich jedoch, dass dies nicht das ist, wonach ich "gesucht" habe. Durch Zufall stieß ich dann auf eine Seite names "Wire of Hope". Es hat ein paar Minuten gedauert, bis ich begriffen habe worum es eigentlich ging. Es ist eine wundervolle Seite, die US-Häftlinge vorstellt, welche auf der Suche nach Brieffreundschaften sind. Zugegeben, hatte auch ich ein paar Vorurteile und dachte mir "Naja, Brieffreunde suchen die sicherlich nicht". Trotzdem hat meine Neugierde gesiegt und ich sah mir ein paar Profile von Insassen an. Was habe ich überhaupt erwartet? Ich weiß es nicht! Die ersten drei Profile waren, mehr oder weniger,  genau das, was ich vermutet hatte. Eben Männer auf der Suche nach etwas, vorzugsweise weiblicher, Ablenkung. Wer kann es ihnen verübeln? Das vierte Inserat las sich jedoch anders. Ich erinnere mich genau an dessen Anfang "Perspective defines individuality. Individuality changes with new perspective. Let us evolve our individualism and share our perspectives. I welcome a conversation with an open mind... " Und da war es, dieses besondere Gefühl. Meine Intuition führte mich nicht zu etwas, sondern zu Jemandem! Justin. 
In 2022, after a wonderfully inspiring evening at a friend's house, I followed my intuition in search of.... Yes, for what actually? I didn't know that at the time. I trusted my inner voice and simply let myself be guided. In the depths of the Internet, I searched pages for writing utensils. I love old fountain pens, ballpoint pens, beautiful paper and great envelopes. I spent hours looking at antique fountain pens, reading poetry and short stories, until I landed on a site for pen pals. I thought it would be nice to find something other than bills in my mailbox. Somehow, however, I felt that this was not what I was "looking" for. By chance I came across a site called "Wire of Hope". It took me a few minutes to realize what it was all about. It is a wonderful site that features US prisoners who are looking for pen pals. Admittedly, I too had some preconceptions and thought to myself "well, they certainly aren't looking for pen pals". Nevertheless, my curiosity won out and I looked at a few profiles of inmates. What was I expecting to find anyway? I don't know! The first three profiles were, more or less, exactly what I had suspected. Just men looking for some, preferably female, distraction. Who can blame them? The fourth ad, however, read differently. I remember exactly how it began: "Perspective defines individuality. Individuality changes with new perspective. Let us evolve our individualism and share our perspectives. I welcome a conversation with an open mind... "And there it was, this special feeling. My intuition led me not to something, but to Someone! Justin.

Beitrag: Infos

Abo-Formular

Vielen Dank!

Beitrag: Subscribe Form
bottom of page